The Book Dummies
The club
Four of us, one night a week, after Macguffins & Muffins closes. Thursday, unless somebody has a reason. There are cocktails, there is a book, and there is a deck of cards, because a book club that only talks about the book runs out of book by nine. We play rummy. We have met for longer than any of us will say in print. We have never agreed on a book. The one title all four of us have signed off on is The Old Man and the Sea, which is why there is a copy by the register. For emergencies.
The name was Marge’s. A dummy is the book before it exists (see below), and she said that was the four of us on any given Thursday: the jacket is fine, the pages are blank, and somebody is swearing it will sell. Em wanted something with a dash in it. Dusty wanted whatever would look best on a jacket. Marge wrote the Book Dummies at the top of the first page of the minutes, in pencil, and it has not been contested since.
The members
Brings the register tape when the others get sentimental and the numbers when they get loud. Working on a rom-com novel that has been nearly finished for some years. Keeps the club’s minutes, which nobody has asked to see.
Pencil, never pen, and never in anyone else’s. Her copies come back with more margin than page and go on the bargain table as pre-read, where they sell first. When the club needs a line from the book, it is Marge’s copy we open.
Starts a sentence about the book, finishes one about the author’s second marriage, and gets back to the book by way of three others. Loves everything, cries at most of it, argues with all of it. The first reader of my novel, which is not a job I advertised.
And is right more often than the rest of us would like. Collects first editions in unclipped jackets, owns three copies of things Dusty has not read, and can name the designer of a jacket from across the room. Reads past the flap copy under protest.
The game
For years the cards were ordinary rummy, played to decide who washes the glasses. Then one Thursday Dusty, who had lost, said you can tell a bestseller by its jacket. Marge said you cannot. Em said both, in one sentence, with a dash in the middle. I went and got the register tape.
By the next Thursday we were dealing jackets instead of cards: six on the table, three trips to the shelf to swap them, and the numbers from the list underneath to settle it. We called it Book Cover Rummy because we deal the covers, and because it is, more or less, rummy. The game on this site is that game, with the glasses washed.
A dummy, since the club is named for one, is the book before it exists: the real jacket wrapped around blank pages, made so a sales rep can put it in a bookseller’s hands and the bookseller can order a book that has not been printed. I have ordered from dummies for most of my working life. Every book in this shop came to me that way first: a jacket, blank pages, and somebody swearing it would sell. Sometimes it did.
So that is what you are playing. Six jackets on the counter. The numbers underneath, if you want to pay for them. Dusty says you can tell. Marge says you cannot. Em says—well. You ring it up and we find out.
Club rules, as kept behind the counter
- Marge may not bring her own pencil. The shop provides one and counts it back.
- Em gets one tangent per book. Em disputes the count.
- Dusty must have read past the flap copy. We check.
- Beth leaves the numbers at the register. The register is eleven feet away.
Where to find them
They turn up in the shelf notes, and now and then in Beth’s Pick, when one of them has a seventh title to push. They recommend. They do not grade. I grade. The cocktails are not on the site. Those are Thursday only.